Greeting Card Advice

I've been trying to put together a holiday box set of greeting cards -- Halloween, Thanksgiving, Christmas and Valentine's Day.

I have great shots already for Halloween and Christmas, so today I thought I'd try shooting some options for Thanksgiving and Valentine's Day. Alfie was uncooperative, but Waffles was willing to help. Unfortunately, she became enraptured with a stuffed turkey I was using as a prop and suddenly it was difficult to get a photo of her that did not include her devouring the toy. I did get a couple and these are two of the best. Problem is I can't decide which I like better for the box set. Wondering if any of you had any opinions. Do you have a favorite?